Compare

2 selected
×Geno Smith
Geno Smith
QB · NYJ · 35y
West Virginia
2025 · 15 G
×J.J. McCarthy
J.J. McCarthy
QB · MIN · 23y
Michigan
2025 · 10 G
Percentile vs Peers2025 · vs peers
Pass Yds/gTD%INT%Y/ACmp%EPA/play
Pocket TimeOn-Target %Avoid PressureAvoid Bad ThrowsAvoid Sacks
SmithMcCarthy
Production
Smith
McCarthy
Pass Yds
3,025
1,632
Pass TD
19
11
INT
17
12
Rush Yds
109
181
Rush TD
0
4
Efficiency & Advanced
Smith
McCarthy
Comp %
67.4%
57.6%
Yards / Att
6.8
6.7
Pass EPA
-72.9
-54.1
CPOE
0.7
-5.7
ADOT
6.2
8.8
Passer Rtg
84.7
72.6
On-Target %
77.0%
66.5%
Bad Throw %
11.4%
21.3%
Pressure %
22.8%
26.5%
Pocket Time
2.5
2.5
Times Blitzed
146
70
2026 ProjectionProjected full-season output (median)
Smith
McCarthy
Pass Yds
3,787
3,125
Pass TD
21.8
16.5
INT
12.7
12.2
Rush Yds
178
239
Rush TD
0.6
4.1
Accolades
Smith
McCarthy
NFL Comeback Player of the Year
1
0
Playoff Games
1
0
Super Bowl Wins
0
0
Contract
Smith
McCarthy
APY
$3.3M/yr
$5.5M/yr
Total Value
$3.3M
$21.9M
Guaranteed
$3.3M
$21.9M
% of Cap
1.1%
2.1%